Patterson Law Firm Secures Defense Verdict for Iowa Farmer in Livestock Collision Case

Patterson Law Firm is proud to announce a defense verdict obtained on behalf of our client, a Palo Alto County cattle farmer, in a case involving an automobile collision with a calf.

The case arose after a driver struck a calf owned by our client, resulting in a property damage claim. The driver’s insurer filed suit alleging the farmer was negligent in allowing his livestock to enter the roadway.

Attorney Andrew Workman represented the farmer at trial. During the case, the defense demonstrated that our client was a careful and conscientious livestock owner:

• He maintained a secure weaning enclosure, reinforced with high-tensile wire, electric fencing, and a backup generator to keep the hotwire active.
• He personally monitored and hand-fed his cattle daily and had never experienced an escape in more than 30 years of livestock care.
• Evidence suggested that the calves were spooked by an unforeseen external factor, such as a wild animal, rather than any negligence in maintaining the enclosure.

Under Iowa law, livestock owners are held to the standard of an “ordinarily prudent and careful farmer” in keeping cattle off the roadway. The jury agreed that our client met this standard and was not negligent.

On June 3, 2025, after deliberating, the Palo Alto County jury returned a unanimous verdict in favor of the defense, and the court entered judgment for our client the following day. The court also assessed costs against the plaintiff.

This case underscores the importance of thorough investigation and effective trial presentation in defending Iowa farmers against claims of negligence. Patterson Law Firm remains committed to protecting the interests of agricultural producers across the state.